- TristanYoshi wrote:
- Hey there, I'm from the US and new to this forum. I'm a film director
Welcome to the forum :-)
Quite a few members have experience using modelguns in movies, they will surely chime in.
Modelguns are quite realistic in some aspects: their slides and frames are often marked similar to real guns,
blowback action is there, with some smoke/flash effects, a bit of bang, and ejection.
Unrealistic aspect would be perhaps that the whole cartridge is ejected, looking a bit different than just the empty shell. It is however the same colour as shell, so not very visible under normal circumstances.
Modelguns are explicitely made in such a way that using blanks is
not an option. They are made of plastic or weak metal (zinc-aluminium), with weak springs, and as a result firing a blank will result in model destruction with parts flying around and large risk to person attempting shooting it. In fact some models have durability issues even with prolonged use of normal caps, due to stress buildup in more fragile materials - especially HW ABS (plastic mixed with metal particles) or old metal models manufactured in 1970s.
There were only a few models made in early 1970s from thin steel, when it was still allowed by Japanese law. Those models could be converted to fire blanks (including strenghtening). They include for example MGC MP40 and Sten.
As for durability - models (except some of the metal ones) are not going to survive being handled a lot, dropped, hit or abused. Most of those cap-firing are made of ABS (plastic) or HW ABS (heavyweight = plastic mixed with metal particles). Slide/frame can crack after being hit, it may also crack after longer use.
Blowback/feeding is not always a breeze, some models tend to require a lot of babysitting to fire reliably, while others are quite mistake-proof.
Tanio Koba is in my opinion the best firing and reliable 1911 model. For a review and my opinion take a look there:
https://mp40modelguns.forumotion.net/t2960-tanio-koba-gm7-colt-1911-hwI would say that this is the best choice as a modelgun. It looks realistic, and it's made of HW ABS material. It is more fragile than ABS, but as those models are just recently made, it's a different story than older models. Cartridges are made of plastic though and do not look like shiny brass shells when ejected. The rest depends on what you expect from the modelgun.
I will let guys with more knowledge comment in more details on practical aspects, hope that all above helps to start gathering the information.